Reason Three to Get the Swine Flu Vaccine – Previously healthy people are almost as likely to die from Swine flu

Spare the Rod? Is Spanking a Child Harmful or Helpful? – Part 5 – Is appropriate spanking harmful to a child?
October 14, 2009
The Grass Is Not Always Greener: A Look at National Health Care Systems Around the World – Part 5 – Germany
October 17, 2009
Show all

Reason Three to Get the Swine Flu Vaccine – Previously healthy people are almost as likely to die from Swine flu

As I recommend the Swine flu vaccine in the office, most healthy adults tell me, “I’ve never had the flu, I have no medical problems, so why should I take it?” The reason was just revealed yesterday when the CDC reported, “of the patients requiring hospitalization, nearly half had previously been in good health.” Until now, health officials had found the most seriously ill adults with the Swine flu (the 2009 H1N1 influenza) had some other medical condition.
But now, Dr. Anne Schuchat of the National Center for Immunization & Respiratory Diseases is saying, “I think a key point is that this virus can be serious, even in healthy people with no underlying conditions.”
ABC World News reported, “Federal health officials today released the largest study yet on adults hospitalized with the H1N1 swine flu. It shows almost half the patients, 46%, had no underlying conditions.”
USA Today reported that Schuchat said that 46% of adults hospitalized for H1N1 influenza “didn’t have a known underlying condition,” reemphasizing, “A key point is this virus can be serious even in healthy people.”
Now, that means that the majority, 54%, of patients admitted to hospitals with severe Swine flu, have medical issues.
The Washington Post reported that the CDC found “asthma is by far the most common underlying condition associated with severe cases of the disease.” Of adults with underlying conditions measured, “about 26 percent had asthma, eight percent had some other chronic lung disease, 10 percent had diabetes, nearly eight percent had weakened immune systems, and six percent were pregnant.”
Meanwhile, “health officials cautioned that the new analysis is preliminary and did not count” as an underlying condition obesity, which other research suggests could be a risk factor for severe H1N1 flu.
For children, “much rarer chronic conditions, such as sickle cell anemia, cerebral palsy and muscular dystrophy, are also predisposing patients to life-threatening bouts of the virus.”
In addition, Schuchat said that “pregnant women are at an unusually high risk for flu complications” because the condition itself is “controlled immunosuppression,” and “the enlarging womb also compresses the lungs.”
The AP calls the results “surprising.” I’d say they are stunning — and add to the reasons that all of you who are healthy should strongly consider both the seasonal flu and the Swine flu vaccines.


  1. JC Ryle says:

    Dr Walt,
    Does it concern you that big-pharma get a total pass on liability for the H1N1 flu shot?

    • Dr. Walt says:

      My understanding is that the liability risk for the vaccine manufacturing, shipping, and distribution for the 2009 H1N1 Swine Flu vaccine is identical to the liability for the 2009 Seasonal Flu vaccine. Let me know if that is not accurate.
      Furthermore, both vaccines have been prepared and tested in exactly the same way by the same manufacturers.
      In fact, had the Swine Flu appeared sooner, if would actually be the H1N1 component of THIS year’s Seasonal Flu Vaccine. And, it’s possible that it will be the H1N1 component of NEXT year’s Season Flu vaccine.
      As to safety, by the CDC’s count, in the US, the death rate from the 2009 H1N1 Swine Flu vaccine is over 4000. The death count from the vaccine is ZERO. The number of serious side effects to the vaccine is ZERO. Seems like a pretty simple decision to me.
      Especially given the prediction, by myself and others (based on the history of past epidemics), that the Swine flu may likely “die down” during the winter, and then (potentially) return with a vengeance next spring. But, I hope I’m wrong!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.