Obama lied about Planned Parenthood and mammograms

The Washington Post has confirmed President Barack Obama lied about the Planned Parenthood abortion business doing mammograms with comments during the debate and with comments the other night on the Jay Leno show.

Obama appeared on “The Tonight Show” Wednesday and suggested that Mitt Romney’s pledge to cut Planned Parenthood funding would deny women mammograms at Planned Parenthood.

Today, the Post confirmed no Planned Parenthoods perform mammograms. Here are the details in a report from LifeNews:

The problem here is that Planned Parenthood does not perform mammograms or even possess the necessary equipment to do so. As such, the organization certainly does not “provide” mammograms in the strict sense. Instead, its clinics provide referrals and direct low-income women toward resources to help pay for the procedure.

These services are by no means unique to Planned Parenthood. In fact, the Susan G. Komen Foundation and the American Cancer Society provide them as well.

Still, Planned Parenthood contends that many women wouldn’t receive mammogram recommendations without the group.

Just to clarify, Planned Parenthood does directly provide breast exams, but only the hands-on variety that doctors administer. This is different from mammograms, which require x-rays.

Obama’s campaign said the president was referring to Planned Parenthood’s broader role as a health-care provider. But the Democratic candidate has repeatedly suggested that the organization provides mammograms directly, indicating more than a slip-up. This claim seems to have become an intentional part of the incumbent’s talking points.

The president has suggested time and again that Planned Parenthood directly provides mammograms, but the organization only offers referrals and helps women find financial resources for the exams. This suggests an intentional attempt to mislead voters about all the services that are at stake with decisions regarding federal funding for the controversial group.

Obama’s campaign points out that the incumbent was referring in each case to Planned Parenthood’s broader role as a health-care provider. But that doesn’t make his remarks any less inaccurate.

We wavered between Two or Three Pinocchios but ultimately decided the president earns Three Pinocchios for his mammogram remarks on “The Tonight Show.” He has repeated them too many times in one form or another for this to be considered just playing with words to generate a misleading impression.

Furthermore, Planned Parenthood admitted last week that it only refers women for them, as any legitimate medical center would do.

Planned Parenthood is not a mammogram provider. A recent paper pointed out that abortion is 125 to 165 times more profitable than mammography. During fiscal year 2009-2010, Planned Parenthood reported more than one billion dollars in net assets.

Moreover, Casey Mattox of Alliance Defending Freedom recently pointed out that, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, no Planned Parenthood clinic in the country is authorized to perform mammograms under the federal Mammogram Quality Standards Act.

One thought on “Obama lied about Planned Parenthood and mammograms

  • A physician emailed me and said:

    Saying he lied is pretty strong. That implies intention. The same thing happens though if the Republicans get rid of Planned Parenthood, women won’t get preventative care as well as birth control as well as no referrals for mammograms. So I believe what he said was true!

    My reply:

    Read the actual Washington Post article. The Post is a fairly liberal paper, certainly very favorable to Obama, but the Post gave this lie a “Three Pinocchio” rating.

    Like the Post says, “The problem here is that Planned Parenthood does NOT perform mammograms or even possess the necessary equipment to do so. As such, the organization certainly does not ‘provide’ mammograms.”

    The Post story goes on to say, “But the Democratic candidate has repeatedly suggested that the organization provides mammograms directly, indicating more than a slip-up. This claim seems to have become an intentional part of the incumbent’s talking points.”

    They go on to say, “The president has suggested time and again that Planned Parenthood directly provides mammograms … This suggests an intentional attempt to mislead voters about all the services that are at stake with decisions regarding federal funding for the controversial group. Obama’s campaign points out that the incumbent was referring in each case to Planned Parenthood’s broader role as a health-care provider. But that doesn’t make his remarks any less inaccurate. We wavered between Two or Three Pinocchios but ultimately decided the president earns Three Pinocchios for his mammogram remarks on ‘The Tonight Show.’ He has repeated them too many times in one form or another for this to be considered just playing with words to generate a misleading impression.”

    In other words, Doctor … repetative misinformation … with the intent to mislead … in spite of the facts … equals a lie … pure and simple.

    BTW, if Planned Parenthood were to get no Federal funds, it won’t be even close to going out of business. I agree with the Republicans. There is no reason for the Federal Govenment to fund a private business like Planned Parenthood … espcecially one that murders the innocent unborn.

    Dr. Walt

Comments are closed.

Enter your email to subscribe to Dr. Walt's blogs.

You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter

There was an error while trying to send your request. Please try again.

Dr. Walt Larimore will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.